November 3, 2015 – 5:00 P.M.
FINAL
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
BOARD MEETING
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
ADDITIONS,
DELETIONS, & SUBSTITUTIONS
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
PAGE ITEM
5 2C-5 ADD-ON:
Proclamation declaring November 2015 as “Joey Bergsma Retinoblastoma Awareness
Month” in Palm Beach County. (Sponsored by Commissioner Taylor)
9 3I-5 REVISED
SUMMARY: Staff recommends motion to approve: Amendment No. 001 to an Agreement
(R2014-0820) with the City of Belle Glade to provide additional funding in the
amount of $9,315.49. Summary: On June 3, 2014, the County entered into an
Agreement (R2014-0820) with the City of Belle Glade to provide $33,171 in
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funding for the lease of three
vehicles to be used for code enforcement activities. The City has requested the
use of $9,315.49 in CDBG funds remaining available after the completion of
another CDBG funded project in the City. In order to further enhance the City’s
code enforcement efforts, this Amendment provides funding for the purchase of
four iPads and their accessories and covers the cost of internet service until
the new expiration of the Agreement on August 30, October 31,
2017. These are Federal CDBG funds which require no local match. (DES
Contract Development) District 6 (JB) (DES)
18 4A-1 REVISED SUMMARY: Staff
recommends motion to approve: A) Amendment
No. 4 to the Agreement (R2011-1975) with the Business Development Board of Palm
Beach County, Inc. (BDB) allocating an additional $500,000 in supplemental funding
for Fiscal Year 2015-2016 and expanding the scope of work;…B)…C)…Summary: On December 6,
2011, the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) entered into an Agreement
(R2011-1975) with the BDB to provide business recruitment assistance, business
retention activities and business expansion services in Palm Beach County. The
BCC and the BDB entered into a public-private partnership to promote the
County, attract new businesses and assist in creating new industries in the
County. The Agreement period is from October 1, 2011, through September
30, 2016, and is in its fifth and final year of the term. This Amendment to the
original base contract of $931,047 $931,470 allocates an
additional $500,000, of which $100,000 one time allocation was included in the
FY 2015 contract, and the remaining $400,000 was approved during the FY 2016
budget process, totaling $1,431,047 $1,431,470. Also, during the
budget process, it was agreed the total amount would be the base budget for the
new five year contract beginning in FY 2017. The additional funding will
continue staffing for the Glades Economic Development Program and provide for
enhanced marketing and advertising activities. The revised scope is provided as
an attachment to the Agenda Item.
These are County ad valorem funds. Countywide (JB) (Admin)
NOTE: Items that were revised, added, deleted, or
backup submitted and were not listed on the addition/deletion sheet distributed
to the Board the prior day are noted with an asterisk (*).
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
BOARD MEETING
PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
TUESDAY COMMISSION
5:00 P.M. CHAMBERS
1. CALL
TO ORDER
A. Roll
Call
B. Invocation
C. Pledge
of Allegiance
2. AGENDA
APPROVAL/SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS
A. Additions,
Deletions, Substitutions
B. Adoption
C. Special
Presentations (Page 5)
3. CONSENT
AGENDA (Pages 6 - 17)
4. REGULAR
AGENDA (Pages 18 - 21)
5. BOARD
APPOINTMENTS (Page 22)
6. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC – 6:00 P.M. (Page 23)
7. STAFF
COMMENTS (Page 24)
8. COMMISSIONER
COMMENTS (Page 25)
9. ADJOURNMENT (Page 25)
* * * * * * * * * * *
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS – 5:00 P.M.
Page 5
2C-1 Hunger and Homelessness Awareness Week
2C-2 National Apprenticeship Week
2C-3 World Pancreatic Cancer Day
2C-4 Alzheimer’s Public Awareness Month
CONSENT AGENDA
A. ADMINISTRATION
Page 6
3A-1 Public
utility easement in favor of FPL related to the Briger property
3A-2 Agreement
with KH Alton, LLC regarding emergency hurricane shelter capacity
B. CLERK & COMPTROLLER
Page 6
3B-1 Warrant
list
3B-2 Minutes
3B-3 Contracts
and claims settlements list
C. ENGINEERING & PUBLIC WORKS
Page 7
3C-1 Proportionate
Share Agreement with CMSJR Development Group, LLC associated with the
transportation impacts of the Okeechobee and Skees Residential project
D. COUNTY ATTORNEY
Page 7
3D-1 Amendment
No. 15 to the Contract with Denise M. Nieman, County Attorney
E. COMMUNITY SERVICES - None
F. AIRPORTS
- None
G. OFFICE OF FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT & BUDGET - None
H. FACILITIES DEVELOPMENT & OPERATIONS
Page 7
3H-1 Amendment No. 1 with Hedrick Brothers
Construction Company, Inc. associated with the Airport Center Building 2
renovations project
Page 8
3H-2 Third Amendment with the City of Boynton
Beach relating to the County’s microwave system to transport radio signals
I. ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY
Page 8
3I-1 Contract
for Consulting/Professional Services with Florida Atlantic Research and
Development Authority relating to provide technical assistance and business
support services to emerging technology companies
3I-2 Amendment
No. 1 with the City of Lake Worth regarding construction of a greenway on 11th
Avenue South (A Street to G Street)
Page 9
3I-3 Contract
for Accounting Services with the Housing Finance Authority of Palm Beach County
and Goldstein, Zugman, Weinstein and Poole
3I-4 Contract
for Audit Services with the Housing Finance Authority of Palm Beach County and
Caler, Donten, Levine, Cohen, Porter & Veil, P.A.
3I-5 Amendment
No. 1 with the City of Belle Glade to provide funding for lease of three
vehicles for code enforcement activities
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CONSENT AGENDA CONTINUED
I. ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY (Cont’d)
Page 10
3I-6 Memorandum
of Agreement with Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council and South Florida
Regional Planning Council establishing a working partnership to be known as the
Southeast Florida Brownfields Redevelopment Coalition
J. PLANNING, ZONING & BUILDING
Page 10
3J-1 Construction
Board of Adjustments and Appeals appointment
K. WATER UTILITIES
Page 11
3K-1 Receive
and file thirteen standard documents for the Water Utilities Department
Page 12
3K-2 Partial
Release of Utility Easement over property owned by Dixie Arbors LLC
L. ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
Page 12
3L-1 Joint Participation Agreement Amendment No.
1 with the Florida Department of Transportation removing redundant
indemnification language relating to a mitigation
project at Snook Islands
M. PARKS & RECREATION - None
N. LIBRARY
- None
P. COOPERATIVE EXTENSION SERVICE - None
Q. CRIMINAL JUSTICE COMMISSION - None
R. HUMAN RESOURCES
Page 12
3R-1 Labor-Management
Agreement with the Communication Workers of America, Local 3181
S. FIRE RESCUE - None
T. HEALTH DEPARTMENT - None
U. INFORMATION SYSTEMS SERVICES
Page 13
3U-1 Interlocal
Agreement for network services with the Town of Lake Clarke Shores
3U-2 Deleted
3U-3 Second
Amendment with Nonprofits First, Inc. relating to network services
3U-4 Twentieth
and Twenty-First amendments with CGI Technologies and Solutions, Inc.
Page 14
3U-5 Amendments
with three vendors relating to digital orthophotography and planimetric mapping
Page 15
3U-6 Agreement
for network services with Max Planck Florida Corporation
V. METROPOLITAN PLANNING ORGANIZATION - None
W. PUBLIC AFFAIRS - None
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CONSENT AGENDA CONTINUED
X. PUBLIC SAFETY
Page 15
3X-1 Contracts
with two vendors for services relating to the Family Drug Court program
Y. PURCHASING - None
Z. RISK MANAGEMENT - None
AA. PALM TRAN - None
BB. YOUTH SERVICES - None
CC. SHERIFF’S
OFFICE
Page 16
3CC-1 National Institute of Justice Award Letter for a FY 2015
DNA Capacity Enhancement and Backlog Reduction Program grant
3CC-2 A Letter of Agreement and Contract with the University of
South Florida (Center for Urban Transportation Research) for the Pedestrian and
Bicycle Safety High Visibility Enforcement project
Page 17
3CC-3 Grant Modification No. 3 with the Office of National Drug
Control Policy for the Palm Beach Narcotics Task Force
3CC-4 A Bureau of Justice Assistance State
Criminal Alien Assistance Program FY 2015 grant
REGULAR AGENDA
ADMINISTRATION
Page 18
4A-1 Amendment No. 4 with the Business
Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc. for supplemental funding to
provide business recruitment, retention and expansion services
4A-2 Resolution
supporting President Barack Obama’s executive action on immigration reform
Page 19
4A-3 Addition
of one full-time Computer Specialist II position
Page 20
4A-4 Criminal
Justice Commission mission, structure, duties and responsibilities
ECONOMIC
SUSTAINABILITY
Page 21
4B-1 Resolution to utilize the State of Florida’s
Brownfield Redevelopment Bonus Refund Incentive Program to support the growth
and expansion of businesses in designated Brownfield areas
BOARD APPOINTMENTS (Page 22)
MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC –
6:00 P.M. (Page 23)
STAFF COMMENTS (Page 24)
COMMISSIONER
COMMENTS (Page 25)
ADJOURNMENT (Page 25)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
2C. SPECIAL
PRESENTATIONS – 5:00 P.M.
1. Proclamation declaring November 14 –
22, 2015 as “Hunger and Homelessness Awareness Week” in Palm Beach County.
(Sponsored Commissioner McKinlay)
2. Proclamation
declaring November 2 – 8, 2015 as “National Apprenticeship Week” in Palm Beach
County. (Sponsored by Commissioner McKinlay)
3. Proclamation declaring November 13,
2015 as “World Pancreatic Cancer Day” in Palm Beach County. (Sponsored by Vice
Mayor Berger)
4. Proclamation
declaring November 2105 as “Alzheimer’s Public Awareness Month” in Palm Beach
County. (Sponsored by Mayor Vana)
5. ADD-ON: Proclamation declaring November 2015
as “Joey Bergsma Retinoblastoma Awareness Month” in Palm Beach County.
(Sponsored by Commissioner Taylor)
* * * * * * * * * * * *
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT AGENDA APPROVAL
A. ADMINISTRATION
1. Staff recommends
motion to approve:
a public utility easement in favor of Florida Power and Light Company and all
other public utilities, and their successors and assigns. Summary: On February 28, 2006, the Board of County Commissioners approved an
Agreement for Donation and Purchase and Sale (R2006-0423) for 70 acres of
property formerly known as Briger for Scripps Phase II. The Agreement provides
for the granting of easement interests for public utility purposes. Countywide
(HF)
2. Staff recommends
motion to approve:
A) an Agreement with
KH Alton, LLC regarding Emergency Hurricane Shelter Capacity in the amount of
$100,000; and
B) a $100,000 Budget
Amendment in the Capital Outlay Fund (3900) to recognize revenue and establish
appropriation budget.
Summary: On April 1, 2010,
the City of Palm Beach Gardens approved a Development of Regional Impact (DRI)
for a 681 acre property formerly known as the Briger Property, consisting of
2.6 million sf of industrial/research and development/biotech, 1.2 million sf
of office, 300 hotel rooms, 500,000 sf of commercial development and 2,700
dwelling units with the County and the Lester Family Investments, L.P. as
applicants. Condition 62 of the Development Order requires KH Alton, LLC to
obtain confirmation from the Emergency Management Department of Palm Beach
County that adequate emergency regular and special needs shelter capacities are
available for the property. The
Agreement memorializes the obligations of KH Alton, LLC and Palm Beach County
as it relates to this Condition of the Development Order. Countywide
(HF)
B. CLERK
& COMPTROLLER
1. Staff
recommends motion to approve:
Warrant List.
2. Staff recommends
motion to approve: the following
final minutes of the Board of County Commissioners’ meetings:
Meeting Type Meeting Date
Regular July 21, 2015
Budget Public Hearing September 21, 2015
3. Staff recommends
motion to approve: Contracts
(regular) and claim settlements list as submitted by various departments to the
Clerk & Comptroller’s Office. Countywide
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
C. ENGINEERING &
PUBLIC WORKS
1. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a
Proportionate Share Agreement (Agreement) with CMSJR Development Group, LLC
(Developer) in a total amount of $773,616 for two proportionate share payments
associated with the transportation impacts of the Okeechobee and Skees
Residential project (Development) (within the City of West Palm Beach). SUMMARY: Approval of this Agreement
will allow the Developer to pay its proportionate share of $773,616. These
payments will satisfy Countywide traffic concurrency
for the Development located at the southwest quadrant of Okeechobee Boulevard
and Skees Road. Pursuant to Florida Statutes, Palm Beach County must enter into
a binding agreement with a developer for its proportionate share of
transportation impacts associated with the Development. District 2
(MRE/LB)
D. COUNTY ATTORNEY
1. REVISED BACKUP: Staff recommends motion to approve: Amendment No. 15 to the Contract (R96-0714D) with Denise Marie Nieman, County Attorney. SUMMARY: This Amendment extends the current contract term to October 31, 2021, allows for conversion of sick leave exceeding a certain number of hours to vacation leave, and otherwise updates and clarifies provisions relating to deferred compensation, renewals, and termination. Countywide (DMN)
H. FACILITIES DEVELOPMENT
& OPERATIONS
1. Staff recommends
motion to approve:
A) Amendment No. 1 to the contract with
Hedrick Brothers Construction Company, Inc. (R2014-0922) in the amount of
$10,836,968 for the Airport Center Building 2 Renovations project, establishing
a Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP); and
B) Consultant Services Authorization (CSA) No.
3 to the contract with Harvard Jolly, Inc. (R2014-0678) in the amount of
$147,526 to provide construction administration services.
SUMMARY:
Amendment No. 1 will provide for the construction of both interior and
exterior renovations to Airport Center Building 2 to accommodate the offices of
the Tourist Development Council (TDC) and related agencies as well as several
divisions of the Sheriff’s Administrative Services including Central Records,
Human Resources, Risk Management and Labor Relations. The costs for this contract have been
allocated on a pro rata share of square footage to be utilized. The Small
Business Enterprise (SBE) participation for this construction contract is 41.4%. Hedrick Brothers is a local firm and it is
anticipated that 92% of the work will be performed by local contractors. The time of construction is 424 days. The source of funding for this project is bed
tax for TDC and Fund 3076 – 66.4M Public Improvement Revenue Bonds, Series
2015A for Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office.
CSA No. 3 authorizes the architect’s construction administration
services portion of its contract. These
services are required to ensure the construction is built per specifications
and drawings. The SBE participation for
Harvard Jolly’s services is 37.3%.
Harvard Jolly, Inc. is a PBC firm. (Capital Improvements Division) District
2 (ME)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
H. FACILITIES DEVELOPMENT
& OPERATIONS (Cont’d)
2. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a Third Amendment to the Interlocal Agreement
(R2001-0200) (the “Agreement”) with the City of Boynton Beach (City) to extend
the term of the Agreement to February 4, 2021. SUMMARY: The Agreement with the City, which provides the terms and
conditions under which the City can use the County’s microwave system to
transport radio signals from the City’s tower to the County SmartZone
Controller expires on February 4, 2016. The Agreement provides for four renewal
options, each for a period of five years. The City has approved a renewal to
extend the term of the Agreement to February 4, 2021 and the renewal now
requires Board approval. Under the terms of the Agreement, the City pays a pro
rata share of the operational and maintenance costs associated with the
microwave system. The costs for each fiscal year are provided by the County by
March 1st annually. The Interlocal Agreement may be terminated by
either party, with or without cause, with one year notice. The Third Amendment renews the terms,
provides for disclosure of County Code Section 2-421 - 2-440 establishing the
Office of the Inspector General, provides for the exclusion of third party
beneficiaries, and adds the standard County nondiscrimination clause. (ESS) Countywide (MJ) (FDO)
I. ECONOMIC
SUSTAINABILITY
1. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a Contract for Consulting/Professional Services
with the Florida Atlantic Research and Development Authority (FARDA) in the
amount of $50,000 for the period October 1, 2015 to September 30, 2016. Summary: This Contract will fund FARDA for operational
expenses of the Technology Business Incubator (TBI) to provide technical
assistance and business support services to emerging technology companies. Through the TBI, FARDA will be required to:
host at least two educational seminars for entrepreneurs, employ ten interns,
arrange two introductory meetings between potential angel/venture capital
investment funds and TBI companies, and create at least five new jobs. This funding is projected to have a five year
Economic Sustainability Impact of $5.5 Million. These are ad valorem funds
approved by the Board of County Commissioners in the Fiscal Year 2016 Budget.
(DES Strategic Planning) Countywide (JB)
2. Staff recommends
motion to approve: Amendment No. 001 to an Agreement (R2015-0630) with
the City of Lake Worth. Summary: On May 19, 2015,
the County entered into an Agreement (R2015-0630) with the City of
Lake Worth to provide $267,396 in Community Development Block Grant (CDBG)
funding for the construction of a greenway on 11th Avenue South from
A Street to G Street. The greenway
includes a landscaped curving multi-use path for pedestrians and cyclists and
driveway access aisles for residents.
This Amendment extends the project completion date from September 30,
2016 to March 31, 2017 and modifies the performance benchmarks to accurately
reflect the progress and completion of the project. The project is delayed due to the City’s need
to install a new separately funded water main in the same location of this
project before the greenway improvements are begun. These are Federal CDBG
funds which require no local match. (DES Contract Development) District 7
(JB)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
I. ECONOMIC
SUSTAINABILITY (Cont’d)
3. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a Contract for Accounting Services between the
Housing Finance Authority of Palm Beach County, Florida (Authority), and
Goldstein, Zugman, Weinstein and Poole, LLC (GZW). Summary: The Authority was established by the Board of
County Commissioners (BCC) in 1979 in accordance with Part IV, Chapter 159, Florida Statutes.
Section 2-189 of the Palm Beach County Code of Ordinances, as amended,
requires that all contracts of the Authority for the purchase of goods and
services in excess of $10,000 be approved by the BCC. This Contract sets forth the terms under
which GZW will provide accounting services to the Authority. GZW was selected by the Authority to provide
accounting services pursuant to a public Request for Accounting Services
process on August 14, 2009. The Contract provides for an initial three year
term and up to two successive three year renewals. The initial Contract was approved by the BCC
on October 6, 2009 (R2009-1628), and this second and final renewal Contract was
entered into by the Authority on September 18, 2015, subject to approval by the
BCC. No match from County General funds is required. (HFA of PBC) Countywide
(PFK)
4. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a Contract for Audit Services between the Housing
Finance Authority of Palm Beach County, Florida (Authority), and Caler, Donten,
Levine, Cohen, Porter & Veil, P.A. (CDL).
Summary: The Authority was established by the Board of County Commissioners (BCC)
in 1979 in accordance with Part IV, Chapter 159, Florida
Statutes. Section 2-189 of the Palm
Beach County Code of Ordinances, as amended, requires that all contracts of the
Authority for the purchase of goods and services in excess of $10,000 be
approved by the BCC. This Contract sets
forth the terms under which CDL will provide audit services to the
Authority. CDL was selected by the Authority
to provide audit services pursuant to a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) process
on August 14, 2009. The RFQ process provided for an initial three year term and
up to two successive three year renewals.
This second and final renewal Contract was entered into by the Authority
on September 18, 2015, subject to approval by the BCC. No match from County
General funds is required. (HFA of PBC) Countywide (PFK)
5. REVISED SUMMARY: Staff
recommends motion to approve: Amendment No. 001 to an Agreement (R2014-0820)
with the City of Belle Glade to provide additional funding in the amount of
$9,315.49. Summary: On June 3, 2014,
the County entered into an Agreement (R2014-0820) with the City of Belle
Glade to provide $33,171 in Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funding
for the lease of three vehicles to be used for code enforcement
activities. The City has requested the
use of $9,315.49 in CDBG funds remaining available after the completion of
another CDBG funded project in the City.
In order to further enhance the City’s code enforcement efforts, this
Amendment provides funding for the purchase of four iPads and their accessories
and covers the cost of internet service until the new expiration of the
Agreement on August 30, 2017 October 31, 2017. These are
Federal CDBG funds which require no local match. (DES Contract Development)
District 6 (JB)
NOVEMBER
3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
I. ECONOMIC
SUSTAINABILITY (Cont’d)
6. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a
Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council
(TCRPC) and South Florida Regional Planning Council (The Council) to establish
a working partnership to be known as the Southeast Florida Brownfields
Redevelopment Coalition (SFBRC). Summary: The TCRPC submitted a Coalition Assessment
Grant application to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on December
8, 2014 as the “Lead Applicant” on behalf of the SFBRC. The SFBRC is
comprised of The Council, Palm Beach County and the TCRPC. On May 28,
2015, the EPA announced the TCRPC’s application resulted in the region
receiving a $500,000 Brownfields grant for the period of October 1, 2015,
through September 30, 2018. The grant is to be used predominantly to
conduct environmental site assessments at potential Brownfield redevelopment
sites located generally within a corridor that encompasses the area between the
CSX and Florida East Coast railroads. As a coalition member, the County
is entitled to a share of the $500,000 award that will fund environmental
assessment activities at prioritized Brownfield sites in the County. This MOA
will show the County’s support for environmental assessment activities in
connection with the grant award, which serve as catalysts for economic
redevelopment projects contributing to the County’s sustainability. The
MOA documents the SFBRC’s site selection process, which EPA requires to be in
place prior to the expenditure of any funds that have been awarded to the
SFBRC. No County local match is required. (DES Administration) Countywide
(JB)
J. PLANNING, ZONING
& BUILDING
1. Staff recommends
motion to approve: appointment of one regular member to
the Construction Board of Adjustments and Appeals (CBAA):
Nominee Seat Requirement Nominated By Term
Margie Walden 9 Citizen at Large Comm. Abrams 11/3/2015–11/2/2018
Comm. McKinlay
Comm. Taylor
Mayor Vana
Vice
Mayor Berger
SUMMARY: Palm Beach County Ordinance 89-31, as
amended in 2002, established the Construction Board of Adjustment and Appeals
(the “Board”). A memo requesting a
nomination for a new regular citizen at large appointment was sent to the Board
of County Commissioners on September 17, 2015. Commissioner Steven Abrams,
Commissioner Melissa McKinlay, Commissioner Priscilla Taylor, Mayor Shelley
Vana, and Vice Mayor Mary Lou Berger have nominated Margie Walden for a term of
three years. Ms. Walden is currently serving as an alternate member on the
Board. Per Palm Beach County Ordinance 2015-028, Palm Beach County Amendments
to the Florida Building Code, 5th Edition (2014), the Board is
comprised of nine regular members: one architect; one engineer; two Division 1
contractors (general, building, or residential contractors); one electrical
contractor; one HVAC contractor; one plumbing contractor; a member at large
from the public; and any other contractor licensed category. In addition to these members, there should be
two alternate members: one member with the qualifications referenced above; and
one member at large from the public. This advisory committee membership has 11
seats, nine currently filled, and a diversity count of White: 9 (100%). The
gender ratio (male: female) is 8:1. Countywide (SF)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
K. WATER UTILITIES
1. Staff recommends
motion to receive and file: executed Agreements received during the
months of July and August 2015:
A) Utility Concurrency Reservation Agreement with
Columbia/Wegman Acquisition II, LLC, No. 02-01142-000, (District 6);
B) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Agreement with Taurus Vista Center, LP, No. 01-01230-000 (District 2), Recorded
in OR BK 27737 PG 1859;
C) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Agreement with W&W XXIV, LLC, No. 05-01115-000 (District 3), Recorded in OR
BK 27766 PG 0799;
D) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Agreement with Cheney 109, LLC, No. 01-01232-000, (District 6) Recorded in OR
BK 27766 PG 0789;
E) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Agreement with Cheney 109, LLC, No. 01-01233-000, (District 6), Recorded in OR
BK 27766 PG 0779;
F) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Agreement with MPC 3, LLC, No. 01-01231-000 (District 6), Recorded in OR
BK 27737 PG 1868;
G) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with FC Atlantic Commons Phase II, LLC, No. 03-01025-003
(District 5), Recorded in OR BK 27737 PG 1855;
H) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with Atlantic Commons Associates, LLLP, No. 03-01025-001
(District 5), Recorded in OR BK 27737 PG 1878;
I) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with Isla Verde Wellington, LLC, No. 01-01194-001 (District
6), Recorded in OR BK 27737 PG 1882;
J) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with Delray 282, LLC, No. 05-01069-000 (District 5), Recorded
in OR BK 27766 PG 0775;
K) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with Town Commons Acquisition, LLC, No. 05-01101-000
(District 3), Recorded in OR BK 27737 PG 1887;
L) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with Lennar Homes, LLC, No. 02-01109-002 (District 6),
Recorded in OR BK 27766 PG 0808; and
M) Standard Potable Water and Wastewater Development
Renewal Agreement with Congress Oaks Development Group, LLC, No. 01-01182-000
(District 3), Recorded in OR BK 27737 PG 1850.
Summary: In accordance with County PPM CW-0-051, all delegated
contracts/agreements/grants/procurement items must be submitted by the
initiating Department as a receive and file agenda item are attached to the
item unless the documents have been recorded in the Public Records of Palm
Beach County. The documents have been fully executed on behalf of the Board of
County Commissioners (BCC) by the County Administrator/Director of the Water
Utilities Department (WUD) in accordance with Resolutions R93-1619, R96-0228,
and R2003-0539 and are now being submitted to the BCC to receive and file. (MJ)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
K. WATER UTILITIES
(Cont’d)
2. Staff recommends
motion to approve: the Partial
Release of a Utility Easement over property owned by Dixie Arbors LLC. Summary: The proposed Partial
Release of a Utility Easement will release the County’s interest in a portion
of a utility easement recorded in the Official Records of Palm Beach County, OR
BK 27278, PG 1920-1923, over property owned by Dixie Arbors LLC. Water Utilities
Department (WUD) determined that a portion of easement inaccurately described
the location of the utility improvements within the Shopping Center as portions
of the improvements were located outside of the easement. WUD subsequently
secured replacement easements that correctly describe the location of the
improvements. As the replacement easements have been received and recorded, WUD
recommends the release of the outdated and inaccurate easement. District 5
(MJ)
L. ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
1. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) approve
Joint Participation
Agreement Amendment Number One with the Florida Department of Transportation
(FDOT) to remove redundant indemnification language; and
B) adopt a Resolution to
authorize entering into the agreement amendment as a requirement of FDOT.
SUMMARY: Amendment Number One to Joint Participation
Agreement (JPA) (R2014-1767) deletes Paragraph 23 removing redundant
indemnification language. The JPA provides FDOT funding for the monitoring and
maintenance of a mitigation project at Snook Islands within the City of Lake
Worth. There is no fiscal impact as a
result of this Board Action. District 3 (SF)
R. HUMAN RESOURCES
1. Staff recommends
motion to approve: the
Labor-Management Agreement with The Communication Workers of America, Local
3181, effective October 1, 2015, through September 30, 2018. SUMMARY:
Pursuant to collective bargaining negotiations, the negotiating committees for
Palm Beach County and The Communication Workers of America, Local 3181, have
reached a tentative agreement on negotiated issues. The proposed three-year
contract incorporating all agreed-upon terms is presented for consideration and
ratification. Countywide (DRO)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
U. INFORMATION SYSTEMS
SERVICES
1. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) approve the Interlocal Agreement for network services with the Town of Lake
Clarke Shores (Town) for an annual revenue total of $3,600; and
B) authorize
the County Administrator or designee, ISS Director, to approve and execute Task
Orders associated with these services, up to a maximum dollar value of $50,000
per Task Order.
SUMMARY: The Town is requesting connection to the Palm Beach
County network at their Town Hall location. This Interlocal Agreement is for an initial
term of one year with automatic one-year renewals unless notice is given by
either party. The Town will reimburse
the County for a one-time installation cost estimated at $7,703 and will
generate $3,600 in annual revenues. The Florida LambdaRail LLC has approved
connection of the Town to the Florida LambdaRail network. District 3
(PFK)
2. DELETED
3. Staff recommends
motion to approve: a Second Amendment to Agreement R2013-1454, as
amended, for network services provided by Palm Beach County (County) to Nonprofits
First, Inc. SUMMARY: Nonprofits First, Inc. has an existing
Agreement, as amended, for network services for an initial term of one year
with automatic one-year renewals unless notice is given by either party. This Second Amendment moves the fiber optic
connection from their existing Boynton Beach location to their new location in
West Palm Beach and reduces network service fees, effective October 1, 2015
based on the revised fee structure recently approved by the Board of County
Commissioners. Nonprofits First will reimburse the County a one-time installation cost
estimated at $1,300 for the fiber installation at their new location. The revised total annual service revenue is
$600 for FY 2016 and succeeding years, a net annual decrease of $2,640. The Florida LambdaRail LLC has approved
Nonprofits First and, on September 21, 2011, waived their fee for connection to
the Florida LambdaRail network. District 2 (PFK)
4. Staff recommends
motion to approve:
A) Twentieth
Amendment to contract with CGI Technologies and Solutions, Inc. (CGI)
(R2002-1782), to extend the ending date of the Statement of Work from December
31, 2015 to December 31, 2016, at no additional cost to the County; and
B) Twenty-First
Amendment to contract with CGI Technologies and Solutions, Inc. (R2002-1782),
to add new Third Party Products (no cost for products) and associated
maintenance services, at an additional cost of $2,813.13.
SUMMARY: This
Twentieth Amendment is a date extension to allow additional time for completion
of the final deliverable specified in the original contract for Vendor
Self-Service bid/solicitation. This
Twenty-First Amendment is for the addition of Third Party Products and
associated maintenance services to the list of existing Third Party Bundled
Software. Countywide (PFK)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
U. INFORMATION SYSTEMS
SERVICES (Cont’d)
5. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) approve
Amendment No. 3 to Contract for Consulting/Professional Services (R2011-2052)
with Surdex Corporation to extend the term of the contract to December 19,
2016;
B) approve
Amendment No. 3 to Contract for Consulting/Professional Services (R2011-2053)
with BAE Systems Inc. to extend the term of the contract to December 19, 2016;
C) approve
Amendment No. 3 to Contract for Consulting/Professional Services (R2011-2054)
with Woolpert, Inc. to extend the term of the contract to December 19, 2016;
D) approve
a Budget Amendment in the Information Technology Capital Improvements Fund to
recognize $131,104 in revenue from the Property Appraiser’s Office;
E) receive
and file Task Order
No. 3 in the amount of $88,288 for contract R2011-2054 with Woolpert, Inc. for
mapping projects; and
F) receive and file
Task Order No. 4 in the amount of $63,000 contract R2011-2054 with Woolpert
Inc. for mapping projects.
SUMMARY:
The three above
referenced firms were selected using the Consultant Competitive Negotiations
Act (CCNA) process, with contracts entered into on December 20, 2011 to perform
digital orthophotography and planimetric mapping for the County (R2011-2052,
R2011-2053 and R2011-2054). These Amendments exercise the third of three
one-year renewal options set forth in the original contracts. Work provided by
the vendors has been of good quality and well managed. Two task orders were
initiated with Woolpert, Inc., and are submitted for receive and file. Task
Order No. 3 is to complete a coastal mapping project, and Task Order No. 4 is
to complete a water utilities mapping pilot project. Both task orders were less
than $100,000 and authorized by the Director of ISS. Countywide (PFK)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
U. INFORMATION SYSTEMS
SERVICES (Cont’d)
6. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) approve the
Agreement for network services with Max Planck Florida Corporation (Max Planck)
for an annual revenue total of $9,600; and
B) authorize
the County Administrator or designee, ISS Director, to approve and execute Task
Orders associated with these services, up to a maximum dollar value of $50,000
per Task Order.
SUMMARY:
Max Planck was
initially included within the original Florida Atlantic University (FAU)
Interlocal Agreement for network services; however, once the County provided
Max Planck with their own separate network connection, FAU requested the
removal of Max Planck from their agreement as it was discovered FAU was only
responsible for providing the fiber access to Max Planck. In response,
Max Planck and the County are proposing to enter into this separate agreement
for the continuation of network services at Max Planck’s location adjacent to
the FAU Jupiter Campus. The Agreement will be
for an initial term of one year with automatic one-year renewals unless notice
is given by either party and will generate $9,600 in annual revenues. The Florida LambdaRail LLC has approved
connection of Max Planck via a separate affiliated agreement directly with
Florida LambdaRail network. District 1 (PFK)
X. PUBLIC SAFETY
1. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) approve a Contract with the Children’s Home Society
of Florida for a not-to-exceed amount of $18,000 to provide services in the
area of Family Drug Court/Dependency proceedings for the period October 1,
2015, through September 30, 2016; and
B) approve a Contract with Drug Testing and Counseling
Services, Inc. for a not-to-exceed amount of $7,500 to provide drug testing
services for the Family Drug Court program for the period October 1, 2015,
through September 30, 2016; and
C) authorize
the County Administrator,
or her designee, to execute minor amendments and administrative documents
associated with the above contracts, on behalf of the Board of County
Commissioners, after approval of legal sufficiency by the County Attorney’s
Office, and within budgeted allocations.
SUMMARY: The
Division of Justices Services, in conjunction with the Fifteenth Judicial
Circuit and other collaborators has operated the Family Drug Court program
since 2010. The Family Drug Court program is a rehabilitation program designed
to identify, case manage, drug test, and provide outpatient and inpatient
substance abuse treatment services to substance abusing parents of abused and
neglected children. The Children’s Home Society of Florida contract provides
case management services, while the Drug Testing and Counseling Services, Inc.
contract provides drug testing services to the participants in the Family Drug
Court program. Countywide (JB)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
CC. SHERIFF’S OFFICE
1. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) accept
on behalf of the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office, a National Institute
of Justice Award Letter for a FY 2015 DNA Capacity Enhancement and Backlog
Reduction Program Grant in the amount of $352,066 for the period January 1,
2016, through December 31, 2017; and
B) approve a Budget Amendment of $352,066 in the
Sheriff’s Grants Fund.
SUMMARY: On September 16, 2015, the Palm Beach County
Sheriff’s Office (PBSO) received an award for the DNA Capacity Enhancement and Backlog
Reduction Program. The Forensic
Biology Unit in the Crime Laboratory of PBSO services over 28 municipalities,
the school systems and assists state and local federal agencies as needed. These funds will
be used for the salary of one Forensic Scientist, equipment, training, travel,
and contractual services that will increase the efficiency of the crime lab.
There is no match requirement associated with this award. No additional positions are needed and no
additional County funds are required. Countywide (JB)
2. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) accept on behalf of the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office, a Letter of Agreement and Contract between the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office and the University of South Florida Board of Trustees for the University of South Florida’s Center for Urban Transportation Research, for the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office’s Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety High Visibility Enforcement Project in the amount of $68,371.88, for the period of October 1, 2015, through May 30, 2016; and
B) approve a Budget Amendment of $68,372 increasing the Sheriff’s Grants Fund.
SUMMARY: On September 22,
2015, the University of South Florida’s Center for Urban Transportation
Research awarded a Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety High Visibility Enforcement
(HVE) grant to the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office (PBSO) in the amount of $68,371.88, to support the Florida
Department of Transportation’s Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety Enforcement
Campaign. These funds will be used to pay for overtime
costs associated with the HVE project. There is no match requirement associated
with this award. No additional positions are needed and no
additional County funds are required. Countywide (JB)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
3. CONSENT
AGENDA APPROVAL
CC. SHERIFF’S OFFICE
(Cont’d)
3. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) receive and file a
Grant Modification No. 3; dated September 9, 2015, with the Office of National
Drug Control Policy to provide an additional $22,000 in grant funds for the
Palm Beach Narcotics Task Force; and
B) approve a Budget Amendment of $22,000 in the
Sheriff’s Grants Fund.
SUMMARY: On March 10,
2015, the Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) accepted an award from the Office of National Drug Control Policy to
provide $30,536, in reimbursable funding for overtime and other expenses to
support the Palm Beach Narcotics Task Force (R2015-0352). On
April 21, 2015, the BOCC received and filed an agenda item increasing the grant
award by $124,470 (R2015-0518). On June
23, 2015, the BOCC received and filed an agenda item increasing the grant award
by $31,902 (R2015-0810). This Modification will provide an additional $22,000
in reimbursable funding to support a Drug Awareness Education Program in
partnership with the Palm Beach County Substance Awareness Coalition and the
Palm Beach Narcotics Task Force. There is no match requirement associated with
this award. No additional positions
are needed and no additional County funds are required. Countywide (JB)
4. Staff recommends
motion to:
A) accept on behalf of the Palm Beach
County Sheriff’s Office, a Bureau of Justice Assistance State Criminal
Alien Assistance Program FY 2015 Grant in the amount of $407,308; and
B) approve a Budget Amendment of $407,308 in the Sheriff’s Grants Fund.
SUMMARY: The Bureau of
Justice Assistance has made funds available to be used for correctional
purposes. These funds will be used in accordance with the Department of Justice
Reauthorization Act of 2005. There is no match requirement associated with this
award. No
additional positions are needed and no additional County funds are required. Countywide
(JB)
* * * * * * * * * * * *
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
A. ADMINISTRATION
1. REVISED SUMMARY: Staff
recommends motion to approve:
A) Amendment No. 4 to the Agreement
(R2011-1975) with the Business Development Board of Palm Beach County, Inc.
(BDB) allocating an additional $500,000 in supplemental funding for Fiscal Year
2015-2016 and expanding the scope of work;
B) a Budget Transfer
of $300,000 from the General Fund Contingency Reserves to the Department of
Economic Sustainability Fund; and
C) a Budget Amendment
of $300,000 in the Department of Economic Sustainability Fund to recognize the
funds from the General Fund.
Summary: On December 6,
2011, the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) entered into an Agreement
(R2011-1975) with the BDB to provide business recruitment assistance, business
retention activities and business expansion services in Palm Beach County. The
BCC and the BDB entered into a public-private partnership to promote the
County, attract new businesses and assist in creating new industries in the
County. The Agreement period is from October 1, 2011, through September
30, 2016, and is in its fifth and final year of the term. This Amendment to the
original base contract of $931,047 $931,470 allocates an
additional $500,000, of which $100,000 one time allocation was included in the
FY 2015 contract, and the remaining $400,000 was approved during the FY 2016
budget process, totaling $1,431,047 $1,431,470. Also, during the
budget process, it was agreed the total amount would be the base budget for the
new five year contract beginning in FY 2017. The additional funding will
continue staffing for the Glades Economic Development Program and provide for
enhanced marketing and advertising activities. The revised scope is provided as
an attachment to the Agenda Item.
These are County ad valorem funds. Countywide (JB)
2. Staff requests
Board direction: on a Resolution of the Board of County
Commissioners of Palm Beach County, Florida, supporting President Barack
Obama’s executive action on immigration reform expanding the Deferred Action
for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and
Lawful Permanent Residents (DAPA) programs; and requesting that Florida
Attorney General Pam Bondi withdraw the State of Florida from Texas v. United States (United States
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit).
SUMMARY: The Board has
requested that a resolution supporting President Obama’s executive action
expanding DACA and DAPA and urging that Florida’s Attorney General Pam Bondi
withdraw the state from Texas v. United
States be drafted and brought back for discussion. Miami-Dade County has passed a similar
resolution, as has the City of Kissimmee.
Twenty-six states, including Florida, have signed onto a lawsuit – Texas v. United States – seeking to
block the President’s executive actions.
At least 76 cities and counties throughout the country, such as Atlanta,
Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, New York, Philadelphia, and the counties of Dallas
and Los Angeles, have signed onto an amicus brief opposing the lawsuit and
supporting the President’s executive action.
In Florida, Tampa and North Miami have joined the brief. Countywide (DW)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
4. REGULAR
AGENDA
A. ADMINISTRATION
(Cont’d)
3. REVISED SUMMARY:
Staff
recommends motion to approve:
A) one full-time Computer Specialist II position
to the Court Technology Division of the Judicial Department-Court
Administration; and
B) Budget Transfer of $64,628 in the General
Fund to move funds from Contingency Reserves to the Court Information
Technology Fund; and
C) Budget Amendment of $64,628 in the Court
Information Technology Fund to recognize the transfer from the General Fund.
SUMMARY: The Court
Technology Division (Division) of the Judicial Department requested two
positions as part of the County’s original 2016 budget submittal and both were
denied by County Administration. After further review of the current work load
data, it is recommended that one position be approved at this time in order to
address the new Supreme Court needs and the increase in court filing. From 2013
to 2014, completed help desk tickets for court technology increased from 4,668
to 5,337. When comparing the first nine months of 2013 to the first nine
months of 2015, the workload (help tickets) increased by 27%. The need
for an additional position exists because, in addition to the judiciary and
Court Administration staff, Court Technology provides technical support for
justice partners within the 77 courtroom and hearing rooms in the five Palm
Beach County courthouses. The position will provide critical support for all
courtroom partners impacted by these newly emerging mandates. The
technologically related mandates significantly increase the amount of courtroom
hardware needed, deployed, and supported by Court Technology staff. The
critical nature of courtroom operations, coupled with the expanding reliance on
technology for court operations, makes it essential that hardware and services
depended upon for court operations are always available. Staff has been advised
that Court Administration plans on requesting an additional computer specialist
position in next year’s budget request prior to the end of the current
fiscal year (September 2016). Countywide (AH)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
4. REGULAR
AGENDA
A. ADMINISTRATION
(Cont’d)
4. Staff requests
Board direction: on the mission, structure, duties and responsibilities
of the Criminal Justice Commission (CJC). SUMMARY: On October 6, 2015,
the Board requested staff to review the mission, structure and functions of the
CJC. The current Ordinance 88-16 established the CJC as an advisory Commission,
to serve as a catalyst to bring together criminal justice and related agencies
in partnerships that cultivate and enrich local criminal justice practice,
policy, and program development. Pursuant to the Ordinance, the Commission
makes recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) on policies
and programs to provide overall coordination to law enforcement and crime
prevention efforts; to provide an efficient, cost effective, and timely
criminal justice system; and to effect the reduction of crime on a permanent basis
in Palm Beach County.
The CJC has an Executive Director and staff to carry out their
mission. A letter of agreement between
the County Administrator and the Chairman of the CJC further delineates the
responsibilities of the Executive Director and staff.
The Executive Director, pursuant to the letter of agreement, shall be
selected by the CJC through a County approved hiring process subject to
approval by the BCC, and is considered a County employee for all administrative
purposes. Further, the CJC Executive Director’s goals and performance
evaluations are developed jointly by the County Administrator and the CJC. The goals and objectives include establishing
task forces and subcommittees, adopting bylaws, entering into contracts, pursue
grant funding and hiring personnel to pursue the mission and objectives of the
Commission.
The Executive Director’s primary responsibilities include implementing
expectations and policies of the Commission, acting on behalf of the BCC and in
consideration with other participating jurisdictions and agencies. Countywide
(JB)
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
4. REGULAR
AGENDA
B. ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY
1. Staff recommends
motion to adopt:
a Resolution authorizing the Department of Economic Sustainability (DES) to
utilize the State of Florida’s Brownfield Redevelopment Bonus Refund Incentive
Program to support the growth and expansion of businesses in designated
Brownfield areas within the County. Summary: The Brownfield Redevelopment Bonus Refund (Program) is available to
encourage redevelopment and job creation within designated Brownfield areas. An
eligible and approved business may receive a tax refund equal to 20% of the
average annual wage of the new jobs created in a designated Brownfield area up
to a maximum of $2,500 per new job created in a qualified area. The Program is a partnership between the
State and local community of which 20% of the award comes from the local city
or county government, unless a waiver of the match is requested. If a local community elects to be exempt from
the local match requirement, the business is only eligible for 80% of the
refund for which they would otherwise qualify, or a maximum of $2,000 per each
new job. To qualify, a business must
locate within a Brownfield area eligible for bonus refunds and be certified as
a Qualified Target Industry business, or be a business that can demonstrate a
fixed capital investment of at least $2 Million in mixed-use business activities,
create at least ten new permanent Florida full-time jobs with benefits, and
demonstrate that the project will diversify and strengthen the economy of the
area surrounding the site. The local
match requirement can consist of direct payments, Ad Valorem tax abatement or
the appraised market value of municipal or county land conveyed or provided at
a discount to the qualified business.
This Program will serve as an additional economic development incentive
program to assist new or expanding businesses. Staff will provide
recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners on a case by case basis
similar to the Ad Valorem Economic Development programs. (DES Administration) Countywide
(JB)
* * * * * * * * * * * *
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
A. COMMISSION
DISTRICT APPOINTMENTS
* * * * * * * * * * * *
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
6. MATTERS
BY THE PUBLIC – 6:00 P.M.
* * * * * * * * * * * *
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
7. STAFF
COMMENTS
A. ADMINISTRATION
COMMENTS
B. COUNTY
ATTORNEY
NOVEMBER 3, 2015
8. COMMISSIONER
COMMENTS
A. District
1 – COMMISSIONER HAL R. VALECHE
B. District
2 – COMMISSIONER PAULETTE BURDICK
Request approval to present off-site, a
Proclamation declaring November 8, 2015 as “Ed Safaty Day” in Palm Beach County.
C. District
3 - COMMISSIONER SHELLEY VANA, MAYOR
D. District
4 – COMMISSIONER STEVEN L. ABRAMS
E. District
5 - COMMISSIONER MARY LOU BERGER, VICE MAYOR
Request approval to present off-site, a Proclamation declaring December
6, 2015 as “Intergenerational Orchestra of America Day” in Palm Beach County
Request approval to present off-site, a Proclamation declaring November
9, 2015 as “Shirley and Barton Weisman Delray Community Center Day” in Palm
Beach County
F. District
6 - COMMISSIONER MELISSA MCKINLAY
G. District
7 - COMMISSIONER PRISCILLA A. TAYLOR
9. ADJOURNMENT
"If a person decides to appeal any decision made by this Commission
with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing, he will need
a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he may need to ensure
that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the
testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based."